I Assure You, We Care
Yesterday, Ongamers’ Thorin wrote a piece on the structure of the LCS split system. The point of the article was that, according to him and the pros he’s spoken with “nobody cares about the spring split”. You can read the original article here, but the basic structure is that because the summer split leads to worlds, the spring split is irrelevant and therefore, the LCS doesn’t work.
For the casual fan, here’s a quick breakdown of the how the LCS season works. The season is divided between two 10-week long halves, called splits. 8 teams participate in each split with the top six advancing to a single-elimination tournament with a large cash prize for the champion of the split. The bottom two teams, and the team who loses out in the playoffs, each must play a best-of-five series against an amature team to keep their spot for the next split. The playoffs for the summer split determine which teams will be sent from each region to the World Championships, where the best team in the world will be crowned.
First, let’s get the obvious fact out of the way. There is certainly more at stake in the summer split for LCS teams with their eyes on greatness. The Summoner’s Cup is the highest achievement any professional LoL player can obtain, and so certainly the split and playoffs that lead to Worlds carry much more importance. No one can dispute that. However, to say that the LCS system is fundamentally flawed because one split carries more meaning is a rather large leap to make. Thorin’s argument is that “no one cares”, so let’s focus first on the people who supposedly don’t care.
The Top Teams
According to Reginald, owner of Team Solo Mid, “Spring Split is a stepping stone. Its used as a practice round to get better by next split, to get into worlds.” This makes a lot of sense. The best teams in the LCS want to compete against the best teams across the world, and the only way to do that is to get into worlds. Therefore every game they play, VOD they watch, and solo queue game they stream is part of their overall preparation to get into worlds. However, there is one thing that puts the spring split above the normal practice regimen–pride. All athletes at the professional level believe that they can win every game they play, and want to win every game. Look at the reaction from TSM’s Xpecial after their loss at the hands of Team Coast this past week. The team is clearly disappointed that their winning streak has been shattered. Why would a team that “doesn’t care” show any emotion at all after a loss? The TSMs and Cloud 9s of the world have to answer to their twitter followers, facebook fans, and stream subscribers after every loss. Sure that loss didn’t affect TSM’s chances at getting into worlds, but they definitely cared about that match.
The Bottom Teams
Thorin’s argument for the bottom teams “not caring” about the spring split is that they aren’t punished hard enough for their poor performance. The sixth place team has too much of a fighting chance to advance, and teams seven and eight still just have to beat a bunch of amateurs to play in the next split. His comparison is that in the National Basketball Association, the eighth seeded playoff team has to play against the best team in their conference, and so their poor regular season performance matters much more than a sixth seeded LCS team. However, no NBA eighth seed is playing for the life of their entire organization. Relegation doesn’t just mean taking a split off. For many players it means the end of their dream. Returning to parents’ homes and school instead of earning a living as a professional athlete. Alternatively, the sixth place team could very well shine under pressure and upset the third place team, suddenly throwing their job security into question. What a fantastic story that makes for the fans. Was anyone complaining about the structure of last year’s spring split when Good Game University got hot and nearly won the whole thing? I for one was cheering them along, hoping they would go the distance. Counter Logic Gaming revamped their entire roster after their loss to GGU, so I’d say its a safe assumption that they cared about that loss.
As for the bottom two teams, they don’t even get a shot at redeeming themselves. Their failure in the regular season means they are one series away from losing everything. Thus far, many of the players that have been relegated are no longer playing League of Legends competitively. Relegation was not a vacation for them, is was the end of their career. While XDG are certainly still in contention, I would imagine that Mandatorycloud and Benny have spent a few sleepless nights wondering what the future holds for them if their team can’t turn it around. Sure all they have to do is beat an amature team. All Complexity had to do last spring was beat the team that became Cloud 9. Most likely the eighth place team this split will have to take on the Chinese powerhouse LMQ. I would wager squeaking into that seventh spot is a pretty high priority for XDG.
The biggest issue with Thorin’s article is that it operates in a purely theoretical space. “A team like XDG can freely experiment with their roster,” he says, “since they know all they have to do is fix things in time to put together enough wins to steal that sixth spot.” Sure, all they have to do is climb out of the complete mess they’ve created, and hope that not only do two other teams lose most of their games, but that XDG can consistently beat those teams, as well as pulling off a few upsets along the way. Because of their losses early on, XDG are no longer in control of their own destiny. The idea that all they have to do is collect a few wins is fundamentally flawed. You cannot plan for a hot streak to just magically occur. Sure, a team can play weird compositions and jungle Soraka all they want if they can catch up at the end, but what if they drop a game? What if they need to “put together” six wins in a row, but they only come out with five? That team that supposedly “doesn’t care” would sure start caring in a hurry.
Think of it this way–why would an NFL team even attempt to win games after they have lost their shot at the playoffs? The NFL draft awards the highest picks to the teams with the worst records, and so with nothing left to play for teams should be focused on scoring the highest picks they can. Even excluding the draft, the risk of injury is so high in football–why risk your star players in an irrelevant season? Because every single person, from the general manager to the head coach to the third string left tackle is playing for their job. The teams with the worst records are usually the teams that make the biggest number of changes in the offseason, and if the third string left tackle isn’t trying every single game, he will most likely be looking for a job at a car dealership in a few months. At least he got a full year’s salary–LCS professionals are only paid for 10 weeks. Their salary is not enough to support them for a full year if they lose their job. The top players are absolutely paid better than the bottom teams simply because they get to keep getting paid.
We The People
Lastly, Thorin argues that the fans ultimately don’t care about the spring split. It’s easily forgettable, because we quickly move on to the next week’s games. Sure, but that’s how every single sport is across the world. During week four of the NBA season, does ESPN spend any air time on games that occurred in week 2? Is anyone still talking about games from last year’s NFL regular season? Is anyone even still talking about the Super Bowl? Even in the vastly more important summer split, will you sit with your friends during week five and chat for hours about How ROCCAT were playing three weeks ago? Spectators live in the moment. The jubilation of a win is completely replaced by the agony of a defeat. Rage at pathetic play can be instantly washed away by landing one flawless Nidalee spear or Thresh hook. As viewers, we vote with our clicks, and the numbers for this “irrelevant” split are in no way disappointing to Riot. Sure we care more when there is more at stake, but ultimately, we just want to watch great games. We want to see Nien fend off all of TSM by himself while minions win CLG the game. We can’t wait to see what crazy thing Darien will bring to the top lane this week. We hope and pray that Hai will bring out his Teemo again. We love this game, and that’s why we watch.
Ultimately, Thorin’s argument holds no water for this reason–we are all watching the spring split. We are discussing every match on Reddit, we are following the madness that is XDG every day. We are quickly minimizing stream windows at work, and calling our friends on the way home for updates. We are criticizing Wickd’s Malphite build, and arguing about whether we are too critical. We care. Riot cares. These professional players who wake up every day getting to live a dream they never thought possible? They care. The spring split may be a stepping stone, but if you don’t care about that first step, you’ll never reach the other side.